This place was great. It is the real deal. Buffet or a la carte. Try some of the smoked meats. Make sure it is open. Closed during winter.
Two B&Bs in Lititz:
www.speedwellforge.com (this one is next door to a wolf preserve with tours on weekends).
This is further away from the heart of Amish country (an hour away!), but resembles Cracker Barrel on steroids. Lots of big buses, but food and service are great if you feel like having comfort food. There is even a Best Western named after it. Strictly if you are in the mood.